Why Bounty Programs Are Ineffective In The War On Money Laundering

Why Bounty Programs Are Ineffective In The War On Money Laundering At first glance, these programs might seem attractive. But they suffer from fundamental flaws. (Shutterstock)

Much like the war on terrorism and the war on drugs, the politics of law-making around the war on money laundering could easily be co-opted to impose Orwellian measures that risk eroding our liberties.

As the political hysteria over money laundering reaches its pinnacle, and as I have pointed out before, policy-makers are resorting to measures, oftentimes first seen in the United States, that would result in serious invasions of privacy.


 Get The Latest By Email

Weekly Magazine Daily Inspiration

Now, there is a growing push to import another Americanism into the Canadian anti-money laundering strategy: a whistleblower incentive program that would amount to bounty hunting for violations.

Implementing a program such as this would not only be unfair, it would be fundamentally ineffective.

The American experience

The U.S. has had bounty hunting programs for banking law violations for some time, presented under the guise of whistleblower protections. Most notably under the Dodd-Frank Act, which encompassed a series of reforms brought about to better regulate Wall Street after the 2008 financial crisis.

An enhanced bounty program for anti-money laundering violations came into effect this January with the passage of the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA). It was included as part of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021, an omnibus bill that passed in December 2020 with bipartisan support, despite former President Trump’s veto.

Under the new AMLA, a whistleblower that reports violations of anti-money laundering laws to the government that results in an enforcement action of more than US$1 million (about C$1.3 million) is entitled to a “reward,” calculated as a percentage of the money collected by the state.

 What is the Dodd-Frank Act?

Under Dodd-Frank, these rewards were capped at US$150,000; but the new AMLA has no cap. Instead, whistleblowers receive a reward of up to 30 per cent of the enforcement action. Given the magnitude of some recent money laundering scandals, whistleblowers could receive hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars.

The AMLA also expands the scope of who may receive a reward to people that were ineligible under Dodd-Frank, such as internal auditors, lawyers or compliance officers — people whose job it is to find and correct behaviour before it turns into misconduct. It also protects whistleblowers from retaliation against their employers.

Crossing the border into Canada

Being our closest ally and trading partner, what happens in the U.S. inevitably influences Canada, and the anti-money laundering bounty hunter program is no exception.

The Ontario Securities Commission has already implemented a similar program and recently made its first payments under the scheme, totalling $7.5 million. Likewise, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has created a bounty program for offshore tax cheating, called the Offshore Tax Informant Program, which offers informants up to 15 per cent of the tax collected relating to the non-compliance they report.

With recent calls to enhance whistleblower protections in this country, it is only a matter of time before we see more programs like this across Canada.

Caught in the crossfire

At first glance, these programs might seem attractive. But they suffer from three fundamental flaws.

First, they are completely reactionary, only rewarding the reporting of misconduct after it has occurred. This means that an employee who finds out about potential misconduct and does nothing, but reports it to the government later, gets a reward. Whereas an employee who stops misconduct from happening, gets nothing. This underscores that when you do things right, people won’t be sure you’ve done anything at all.

Second, research suggests that financial incentives like these may actually decrease whistleblowing, which upends its entire purpose.

Third, and most troublingly, as I’ve raised previously in relation to the CRA’s offshore tax informant program, bounty programs like this create a strong incentive to provide misleading or unreliable information in the hopes of receiving an award.

It has long been understood in the criminal law context that information provided based on the hope of gaining an award or advantage — particularly from someone who may themselves be implicated in the wrongdoing — is unreliable. This lesson was only learned in the criminal law sphere after countless wrongful convictions.

Anti-money laundering policy-makers would be wise to look to these unfortunate experiences before extending a fundamentally flawed structure to yet another facet of our legal system.The Conversation

About The Author

Joven Narwal, Adjunct Professor at the UBC Allard School of Law, University of British Columbia

Recommended books:

Capital in the Twenty-First Century
by Thomas Piketty. (Translated by Arthur Goldhammer)

Capital in the Twenty-First Century Hardcover by Thomas Piketty.In Capital in the Twenty-First Century, Thomas Piketty analyzes a unique collection of data from twenty countries, ranging as far back as the eighteenth century, to uncover key economic and social patterns. But economic trends are not acts of God. Political action has curbed dangerous inequalities in the past, says Thomas Piketty, and may do so again. A work of extraordinary ambition, originality, and rigor, Capital in the Twenty-First Century reorients our understanding of economic history and confronts us with sobering lessons for today. His findings will transform debate and set the agenda for the next generation of thought about wealth and inequality.

Click here for more info and/or to order this book on Amazon.


Nature's Fortune: How Business and Society Thrive by Investing in Nature
by Mark R. Tercek and Jonathan S. Adams.

Nature's Fortune: How Business and Society Thrive by Investing in Nature by Mark R. Tercek and Jonathan S. Adams.What is nature worth? The answer to this question—which traditionally has been framed in environmental terms—is revolutionizing the way we do business. In Nature’s Fortune, Mark Tercek, CEO of The Nature Conservancy and former investment banker, and science writer Jonathan Adams argue that nature is not only the foundation of human well-being, but also the smartest commercial investment any business or government can make. The forests, floodplains, and oyster reefs often seen simply as raw materials or as obstacles to be cleared in the name of progress are, in fact as important to our future prosperity as technology or law or business innovation. Nature’s Fortune offers an essential guide to the world’s economic—and environmental—well-being.

Click here for more info and/or to order this book on Amazon.


Beyond Outrage: What has gone wrong with our economy and our democracy, and how to fix it -- by Robert B. Reich

Beyond OutrageIn this timely book, Robert B. Reich argues that nothing good happens in Washington unless citizens are energized and organized to make sure Washington acts in the public good. The first step is to see the big picture. Beyond Outrage connects the dots, showing why the increasing share of income and wealth going to the top has hobbled jobs and growth for everyone else, undermining our democracy; caused Americans to become increasingly cynical about public life; and turned many Americans against one another. He also explains why the proposals of the “regressive right” are dead wrong and provides a clear roadmap of what must be done instead. Here’s a plan for action for everyone who cares about the future of America.

Click here for more info or to order this book on Amazon.


This Changes Everything: Occupy Wall Street and the 99% Movement
by Sarah van Gelder and staff of YES! Magazine.

This Changes Everything: Occupy Wall Street and the 99% Movement by Sarah van Gelder and staff of YES! Magazine.This Changes Everything shows how the Occupy movement is shifting the way people view themselves and the world, the kind of society they believe is possible, and their own involvement in creating a society that works for the 99% rather than just the 1%. Attempts to pigeonhole this decentralized, fast-evolving movement have led to confusion and misperception. In this volume, the editors of YES! Magazine bring together voices from inside and outside the protests to convey the issues, possibilities, and personalities associated with the Occupy Wall Street movement. This book features contributions from Naomi Klein, David Korten, Rebecca Solnit, Ralph Nader, and others, as well as Occupy activists who were there from the beginning.

Click here for more info and/or to order this book on Amazon.



This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

English French Spanish

follow InnerSelf on

facebook icontwitter iconyoutube iconinstagram iconpintrest iconrss icon

 Get The Latest By Email

Weekly Magazine Daily Inspiration

MOST READ

Some Of My Friends Are Black Racism
"Some Of My Friends Are Black" Racism
by Christopher Parker, University of Washington
The US White Majority Will Soon Disappear Forever
The US White Majority Will Soon Disappear Forever
by Dudley Poston and Rogelio Sáenz
Internet connected devices like webcams are the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the Internet of Things. DAVID BURILLO/Flickr, CC BY-SA
Is Someone Watching You Online? The Security Risks Of The Internet Of Things
by Patryk Szewczyk, Lecturer, Edith Cowan University
technology and inequality
More Technology Doesn’t Mean Less Inequality
by Aim Sinpeng, University of Sydney
How Chemical Recycling Technology Could Help Fix Plastic Pollution
How Chemical Recycling Technology Could Help Fix Plastic Pollution
by Matthew Jones and Jack Payne, University of Bath
Australia Is At A Crossroads In The Global Hydrogen Race
Australia Is At A Crossroads In The Global Hydrogen Race
by Thomas Longden, Australian National University, et al
Many Qanon Followers Report Having Mental Health Diagnoses
Many Qanon Followers Report Having Mental Health Diagnoses
by Sophia Moskalenko, Georgia State University
How Our Health And Happiness Depend On A Thriving Planet
How Our Health And Happiness Depend On A Thriving Planet
by Melissa Marselle, De Montfort University
How Droughts And Floods Lead To Migration And What To Do
How Droughts And Floods Lead To Migration And What To Do
by Cameron Fioret, University of Guelph and Nidhi Nagabhatla, McMaster University
Climate Action And Job Creation Are The Top Priorities For Canadians
Climate Action And Job Creation Are The Top Priorities For Canadians
by Michael M. Atkinson and Haizhen Mou, University of Saskatchewan

New Attitudes - New Possibilities

InnerSelf.comClimateImpactNews.com | InnerPower.net
MightyNatural.com | WholisticPolitics.com
Copyright ©1985 - 2021 InnerSelf Publications. All Rights Reserved.